Menu +
Subscribe to the weekender

Most Romantic Restaurants

Most romantic restaurants, ranked.

1.  ? Cucina Bella, Algonquin; reservations: 847.458.2504

  • “The food far surpassed our expectations and everyone was extremely attentive. Our server, Peter, was hysterical and played right into our shenanigans! Best night out in a long time. Plus, the tiramisu was to die for.” Missy P., Algonquin 


2. 1776, Crystal Lake; reservations here or 815.356.1776

  • “Excellent presentation! Amazing farm-to-table dishes! And under new ownership with a complete renovation!” Sebastian F., Crystal Lake 


3. Montarra, Algonquin; reservations here or 847.458.0505

  • “I had the New York strip steak it was cooked to perfection and such great flavor. Garlic mash was awesome. A five-star restaurant in the far west burbs.” Bill A., Des Plaines 


4. da Baffone, Crystal Lake, reservations: 815.893.6149

  • “Wonderful food, service and atmosphere! My husband had the chicken marsala and I had the shrimp fettuccini alfredo. We loved It! We shared a bottle of prosecco. The waiter even gave us complimentary lemoncello. Yum!” Karley S., Crystal Lake 


5. Paisano’s, Richmond, reservations: 815.678.4500

  • “We had an exceptional dining experience. Our first time, I had linguine with white clam sauce and my date had veal picata. Fabulous. Service was good. Reservation made and we were seated on time. Four stars … will return.” Denise A., Antioch


Details are subject to change at any time – always call ahead! 

Ranking based on Facebook fan votes. Subscribe to our Facebook Events Page to cast your vote in our polls. 


Cucina Bella
Cucina Bella, South Main Street, Algonquin, IL, USA
1776 Restaurant, West Virginia Street, Crystal Lake, IL, USA
Montarra, South Randall Road, Algonquin, IL, USA
da Baffone
da Baffone Cucina Italiana, North Main Street, Crystal Lake, IL, USA
Paisano's, Broadway Road, Richmond, IL, USA

©2019 McHenry County Living. All Rights Reserved. | Cary, IL | 815.900.8522 | Site by 82 Birds

back to top